A lot of guys tend to get too intense after their first online date that they have with a woman. That being said, it’s important to remember that following up with her isn’t stalking. You just need to be as relaxed and fun-loving as you were before, and she’ll be just as comfortable with you as she was before.
Wait a day.
Even if your date was amazing, we highly recommend just waiting a date before contacting her. Remember how it was on all the real online dating sites that you used to meet her–you don’t want to come off as desperate. You just want to come off as a nice guy.
Check on her, and ask her how she’s doing. Tell her you had a great time, and that you’d love to see her again in the near future. There’s no need to set a date right away; you both have plenty of time to do that later.
If there’s no response, try an e-mail.
Don’t ever call her. If you do that, she’ll just end up thinking that you’re some weirdo off of a discount online dating site, and that’s the last thing that you’re going to want.
If she doesn’t reply to your text or e-mail, then there’s a pretty good chance that she’s not into you. Don’t harass her from that point on. You don’t want to be the guy that ends up on any online dating site reviews as a really big creep that just won’t leave her alone.
She also just might be busy. You can try a week later, and if she responds then, then she probably was just overwhelmed by the stress of real life. This is why we always recommend just taking it slow, no matter how amazing the date was or how into her you are.
Don’t overload her.
The last thing you want to do is harass her. It’s never going to go well, so just take it slow, and your results will be that much better.